Magnet

Hello Peter,

I wouldn't claim this is the source of your problems, but such problems can occur where the wiring into the door from the A post - via the flexible rubber sheathing - has become brittle over time and one or more wires almost/do  break. This section of the harness really does get a bit if a hammering, particularly in the colder months where insulation becomes more brittle. It might be worth peeling back the flexible sheathing and just checking there before delving any further.

Good luck in sorting it out.

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Thanks Scott,

Well Trevor - great minds think alike. Although in my case it could be idiots always agree!

Seriously, this looks more like a B&Q ordinary mild steel rough-as-a-badger's-backside threaded screw rather than a high tensile set bolt. Probably simply sheared at some stress raiser point along the thread where these threads are rough. 

Surely, surely, this is not a VAG sourced part ( please tell me it's not Scott), but looks suspiciously like it may have been made very far east of the English channel and found its way to the local motor factors or an eBay listing. 

Really interested in this, since I'm sure someone else has had a similar experience. 

Kind regards,

Gareth. 

Mileage is 84,561 Steve.

Kind regards,

Gareth. 

Hello Scott,

To other forum contributors:- Am I right in thinking someone else asked about this type of issue some time ago? 

If so, I think I asked for details of where the fracture occurred ( but we didn't get an answer?). Could you let us know Scott, and ideally post a photo of the point of shear. My guess at it would be at what is call the run out of the thread I.e where the thread ends. 

Another point of interest would be the actual supply source of this part. VAG main dealer, or aftermarket? 

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Keith,

I wonder what year these cars you have been looking at are. I ask, since it may help if you look under the recall section of this forum where you will see there had been performance issues with cars which have been subject to these recalls. I just wonder if you have been road testing so called rectified recalled cars.

Whatever, most folks will stress the vital importance of service history, as if it's the be all and end all - in itself - of the freedom from major mechanical issues. I take a broader brush approach and always recommend talking with the last registered keeper about the car , since thereby hangs the full tale of how the car has bahaved itself between its visit to the dealer for servicing! 

Good luck with finding the car which suits you, and if it were me, I would be doing as much pre purchase research on the actual car which finally interests you, and try to take a detached view on the falling in love with the look of it bit.

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Phil,

Just a couple of questions;- Is the car fairly new to you, or have you had experience of it handling better prior to doing the suspension work?

What make tyres do you have on it and what would you say is the remaining tread depth?

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello John,

Glad the cause has been established, and I take no comfort from the fact that my diagnosis ( via. the question of which two cylinders were lower) turned out to be correct.

Now, your sophisticated diagnostics is fine, but being from the old school of mechanic-ing as the great Fred Dibnah used to say, I tend to look at symptoms and ask questions and take a logical approach to these things. Those compression figures just jump out at them, and irrespective of knock sensors etc.etc. it just shouts head gasket blowing between the two adjacent cylinders and passing opposing pressure onto the neighbouring cylinder - which says 'this isn't right - I going to let you know by pinking" . Thimple, as our friends on hind legs would say! 

Machanic-ing with logic should over rule the diagnostics, and the garage's failure to spot this problem from the outset, has done serious damage to that which sits in your back pocket! Great shame. 

Still John, the beloved car is going to be well again and that is important.

Back to those compression figures - I shudder at their interpretation of valve problems. Oh dear dear me!  I ask, is there still a need for the elderly here or should we (elderly) all be sitting in homes out of the way? I've probably got shoes older than these chaps, and I guess I should now have forgotten most of what no one taught me in the first place!  Jovial rank over.

Good luck with it John,

Kind regards, Gareth. 

"I'm hoping you are not taking your A6 back there again?!" 

Um?? Battles won can give satisfaction, but battles they are, and battles simply equals hassle. I think a lot of people will echo your comment Steve. 

Of course, there might be a school of thought that these people "owe me" a couple more free MOTs and the fact that this year's battle has been fruitful in the end, that it's worth returning next year to have a similar chance of satisfaction if another battle is necessary. 

Would I be right in thinking most of us on here would simply steer well clear of whatever is left of this "free MOT" , and simply foster good relations with a local MOT station? 

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Cameron,

I share Dan's comments, and I feel he is being as polite as can be in his reaction to what many would consider to be an almost unbelievable quote! 

Question regarding whether you can get this done at a non-Audi garage is I think answered by yes you can, providing the approved "parts" are used by the (VAT registered) garage doing the work and they provide you with receipts for the parts and work done.

If it were mine, I would first follow Dan's advice and get an alternative quotation from another Audi dealer. My suspicion here is that you might be assuming it requires an oil (and filter) change whereas the car is due for a service, and they have quoted you for the service and not simply just changing the oil and filter. 

Let us know on that Cameron, and if indeed you are correct with this charge for simply changing the oil, then we can advise you what options you have from there. No point in going through it all until this bit is clarified.

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Dayan,

I'm sure I am not experienced enough to answer your questions, but perhaps some of the following may be useful to know while others far more experienced than me offer you meaningful advice. 

What I would ask is, are you an "enthusiastic" driver and welcome road holding over comfort, or is the S Line of more interest to you than the SE due to the S Lines looks etc? I think thereby lies the answer to your question, and of course, you have to be the judge of this. Compromises are always necessary, but I really think it does boil down to which of the two is more important to you. I'm sure others will assist you much more than I once they know your preference. 

On a personal note, I have a non-Audi sport variant (bought used) but I bought it due to its condition and equipment, and in preference, I would have preferred the non-Sport model if I could have found an equally nice one. My preference is for ride comfort rather than throwing it around corners, but in my case availability decided the choice.

I think you are very wise to seek good advice before committing. 

Good luck, 

Gareth.

Hello Dave,

That's great and interesting news. Interesting from the point of view that these differences normally come out the other way, and you can (sometimes) find that you get a more competitive quote by going direct to the insurer. In your case thst obviously hasn't worked.

I guess you have no doubt confirmed that the actual level of cover you are getting is exactly the same as that which you had via. your direct quote, since comparison sites are generally set up to list the cheapest possible cover from each insurer. Things like reasonable excesses, courtesy cars, legal protection, NCB protection etc., etc. then become 'add-ons' at additional premiums. 

Thanks for sharing this. Kind regards,

Gareth.

ADMIN. folks:- Worth moving this to Insurance topic? 

Hello Lee,

Thanks for coming back on this. If the registration throws up the possibility of two different types then there there are three ways to possibly resolve which are the the correct ones (in ease of doing):-

Contact the seller and ask if they would know from the VIN? which would be the correct one.

Contact your local Audi dealer - give the VIN - and ask the same question, get the Audi part number and refer back to the eBay seller.

Take one pad out, measure and photograph it, and then identify which one you need to buy.

"I assume I can buy any pad as long as they correspond with the the right discs- yes?"

Answer is indeed yes, once you know what are the the correct part number pads you want.

I'm sensing cheapest correct ones wins here! 

The only good example comparison I can make for you is:- You need a new pair of trainers, so you go along to the local Sunday market stall and buy the cheapest ones that fit you - yes?

Probably no, and I guess you would want the better quality at the best price.

Brakes are meant to save your life - and others, and cheap means cheap, and you will find out they don't stop you as good as Audi/quality brands, and they just won't last as long. Beware, even brands once recognised as being amongst the best aftermarket quality, are now simply bought-out brand names and those names supposedly bringing some degree of respectability to the parts! 

I'm from the school of buy once and wisely, and it might be worth bearing in mind that you are saving a fair amount in labour by doing it yourself, so why scrimp on cheapest parts? 

Obviously your call Lee, and good luck in finding what you need. 

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Lee,

They should be able to identify the correct ones when you let them know what your registration number is.

Wondered what brand of brake pads you were thinking of buying, and whether you were indending to go for the best price deal.

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Jay,

The compression test will confirm what it says, and despite good sealing compression rings, the oil control rings may well be rather past their prime and not adequately preventing oil passing through the rings and getting burnt. 

Having said that, you don't tell us whether the car is actually now known to be burning oil and if so at what rate. What mileage has it done Jay, and what do you know about its servicing history - or lack of it. Not meaning to be unkind, but judging by the photos you posted of part of the engine it looks like the dear little thing might benefit from a bit of loving care in the servicing department.

I say this, since if it were mine, I would add some oil flushing agent and follow the instructions for its use. Then drain the oil, treat it to a good (say VAG or Mann) oil filter and add fresh - say fully or semi synthetic 15/40 (a bit heavier than recommended probably) to the  max. line, then monitor the smoke and consumption from there and see how it goes. 

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Jay,

Well done on the good progress so far. 

Smoke isdues :- I would ask a question to add to Dan's. Do you know if this car uses any appreciable amount of oil? 

While we await your answer, I too would start to suspect possible injector/s problems, and wonder whether you have any stronger than normal diesel smell when this is smoking? May be difficult to detect on your own, so a following assistant would be handy! 

Diesels are not my field of expertise - what is!? - but if it's not burning oil, and it's not now consuming coolant, then it's not correctly burning the diesel it is being fed. So could well be injector associated issues. 

Fairly simple test - for those who have the equipment - is a leak-back test which will point you towards whether the injectors are serviceable or not. If not, an alternative to buying new (expensive?) could be to find a local diesel specialist who generally recondition these at a more reasonable cost over new.

Kind regards,

Gareth.

The original S Types I guess Joe, when you refer to rusty. Nice. My Prescott involvement was with a pair of the more modern aluminium bodied ones - body weight being the same as the Toyota Varis. Still have the one. That gets Autoglymed! 

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Lovely job. I starting using Autoglym when I had hair, and that's a long time ago! I've tried others from time to time, but always returned to it. I'm not saying it's the best, but I find it to be good enough. 

The comment about metallic, generally doesn't apply any more (and hasn't for a couple of decades) since all the finishes - metallic and 'solid' - are now to the system of clear-over-base, where the colour is overcoated with the clear gloss lacquer. The polishes therefore do not 'attack' the metallic colour as it used to, but simply cleans/polishes the lacquer, so little cause for concern. 

I did find their leather cleaner and balm to be very good on no.2 car of the same model, when I had a fairly brief John Prescott period a year or so ago! 

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Shaun,

There has been some issue about valves in the ABS causing the traction light to come on. I'm not sure whether it would interfere with the brake lights - but possible I guess. Probably others on here will be able to help you out with other advice, but this may be worth doing a search on.

If it does prove to be this, then VAG do/did do a part replacement of the offending section of the ABS unit. Not cheap of course, but you should be able to get some discount at some dealers.

I hope other members here may be able to help with some advice.

Kind regards,

Gareth.

p.s. May have got this wrong, but aren't there two brake (light) switches on these? Worth checking, and checking the other one if its there? 

Hello Ian,

Welcome to the forum. It certainly seems you have your head around what you are doing, and I too would suspect that the recent lambda sensor fitted by the previous owner might well have been the much cheaper generic type rather than a genuine VAG one. Understandable I guess, if he knew he was selling the car. Swopping them is an option as you say, or seeking more specialist advice/assessing equipment via. an independent. A small investment there might save you in the long run. 

Generic sensors can sometimes be identified by slightly different wiring colours and usually more 'cobbled" looking connectors.

If it turns out this sensor is the offender and you know they cost £180 from VAG, it may be worth shopping around to see what discounts you can get. I have bought quite a bit off one dealer with discounts and good service, and I am happy to share this with you should you need it. No doubt there will be other dealers offering such discounts. 

Good luck in getting it sorted.

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Anvi, 

Mark has also been there, tried it, by the look of it, and it would seem we are both on the same wave length. Great that you have two keys, but I'm not sure from what you say, whether both keys behave the same. 

There has been a fair amount of experience to show that DIY type attempts to reprogramme don't work for all ( to be kind) and whatever we think, the solution lies with those who have the necessary equipment to re programme them. If it has to be fixed then it's getting the wallet out time it seems. 

I did advocate finding an independent since they are very often more accessible to be able to talk with, rather than just being able to talk with the front desk at main dealers. OK, take your point about Audi dealer/s being a rip off, but you have to consider they invest vast amounts of money to set up and maintain their businesses, and it just ain't cheap to do that. Shopping around main dealers and independents, and doing the homework is generally low cost/free so that would be the best advice I could offer, unless anyone comes up with a 'for free' solution for you.

Good luck in getting it sorted.

Kind regards,

Gareth,

Hello Avni,

My experience with these remotes is that 'left unattended" for some time, can render them inoperable except as a key, and you will experience just what you are experiencing irrespective of fitting a new battery. There are numerous documented accounts on how to DIY re programme the remotes. I've tried them all, and some I've thought of! -  with my original spare remote. No luck.

I think you will find this needs to be plugged in and re synchronised. An independent might be able to assist. Can we take it you only have one remote rather than having a spare as well?  Just asking since if you have two, then you may be able to get both done at the same time, for little more than you will pay for one. 

My recommendation is not to use £ shop batteries in the remotes. You could be lucky and they last, but just not worth the risk.

Kind regards, 

Gareth.

Well done you.  Just proves it only takes 1 in 60odd million to want to buy a car we want to sell. Just goes to show then. Thanks for letting the forum know and good luck with your next purchase. 

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Steve,

Apologies for putting a potential dampener on your sale , but I guess you are not putting this car in part exchange possibly because of the considered low offer. Perhaps I'm wrong.

What I would realistically be asking myself is how many buyers are out there who have access to a cool 26 grand in their pocket and are looking to buy your car. It might be wise considering that if there is someone out there then they will be buying you car without access to dealer finance, without being able to part exchange their current car, and most importantly with any warranty. Knocking £200 off may be some sort of incentive, but.....

Yes, I know all of this is pessimistic, but what are you going to do if it doesn't sell, and you have two vehicle to insure etc. Etc. The main reason for me to be mentioning all of this is, that if you were to put in part exchange then it's gone, if you don't, and you can't sell it, you can't go back to the dealer and expect them to buy it ( well at least at what they are offering you now) - the boat will have been missed. 

Apologies if I've got this all wrong, and genuinely, I wish you all good luck in finding your buyer.

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Justin,

Perhaps this may appear to be a daft question, but is this creaking problem less if a problem in wet conditions? My feeling is that this is a dry bush issue - and there will be numerous ones, and well worth getting an assistant to listen to try to find out which corner emits the noise. 

I see the car is about 3 yaers old, and it would probably benefit from a dosing with a WD40 type spay on all bushes and moving parts anyway. Obviously pay respect to shielding the brake discs from any overspray. 

I have found that GT85 (with PTFE) to be a good/better? alternative to WD40, and being Welsh it matters that it is cheaper. I understand sales in Scotland have gone through the roof, whereas WD sales are in decline! Only joking.

Kind regards,

Gareth.

Hello Kal,

From the school of eliminating the simple things first, I would not consider major wallet-affecting issues before first eliminating that the battery is not the cause of your issues. Prior to the stop- start technology, original batteries usually lasted a good 10 years. Now, with so called intelligent charging batteries, stop-start, etc. who knows how long they will last. I would normally have suggested you get your battery's efficiency checked  by say Halfords, but I 'm not sure with this modern technology. Probably worth having a word with your local indi first.

Kind regards,

Gareth.